American Idol: Separated at Birth
Wild Bluff Media » American Idol, Celebrity, TV » American Idol: Separated at Birth

We know that our fans are fascinated with the private lives and even more private secrets of the latest batch of American Idol contenders. Here at Wild Bluff Media, we have had our crack team of investigators scouring the archives, pulling medical records, bribing family friends, and diving in trash cans to bring you this breaking story (OK we spent about 20 minutes on the internet). We have dredged up all of those disturbing family secrets that these contestants would rather you didn’t see:

Idol on iTunes

Stephanie Edwards : Fantasia
Hey, didn’t you win already?

Edwards

Jared : Jared
Separated at birth, you decide.

Jared Cotter

And of course, Love her or hate her…

Antonella Barba : Horse
Neigh.

Antonella Barba

OR

Antonella Barba : Tera Patrick
Next Vivid Video Girl?

Antonella Barba

Brandon Rogers : Chia Head
Ch-Ch-Ch-Chia!

Brandon Rogers

Sanjaya Malakar : Mowgli
Look for the bare necessities…

Sanjaya Malakar

Sanjaya Malakar : Michael Jackson
Even scarier, all he needs is the white glove

Sanjaya Malakar

Chris Sligh : A Shrub
A little gardening my be in order.

Chris Sligh

Sabrina Sloan : Barbara Streisand
Yentl’s illegitimate black stepchild?

Sabrina Sloan

Phil Stacey : Nosferatu
Phantom of the Night (Dude and the hat doesn’t help)

Phil Stacey

Sundance Head : Heat Miser
Who was your father again?

Sundance Head

Blake Lewis : Justin Timberlake
Boy Bands ‘R Us

Blake Lewis

Melinda Doolittle : DW
Arthur’s older scarier sister?

Doolittle

Chris Richardson : K’Fed : BritanySpears
They all have the same haircut.

Chris Richardson

American Idol Updates

Written by: Walt
Posted on: Tuesday, March 13, 2007

13 Responses to “American Idol: Separated at Birth”

  1. Random Ass Blog

    Don’t forget to vote for Sanjaya Malakar!!!!

    Im not one of those guys that does anything with a lot of ambition, but I think I finally found something I can get behind: Sanjaya Malakar.

    I say we send a message to the world and make him or idol for the following reasons:

    A) To teach the Religious Right that even a homo can be our idol.
    b) And to prove an important point about outsourcing:

    If we need to speak to a f’ing indian dude everytime our computer breaks down, then america will be forced to listen to this little queen for the next year…

  2. WildBluff_Matt

    Hilarious. Man, I’d get a kick out of seeing Sanjaya win.

  3. Frank

    That was harsh post. Hilarious but harsh. Although the Antonella = Vivid girl is probably right on the money for next year.

    And that Britney photo seems to remind me of most of the guys that I know. Her career has officially ‘jumped the shark’.

  4. WildBluff_Matt

    Jump the shark is right. At least we’ll always have the good ol’ years of Britney to look back on.

    Although Antonella Barba swears she won’t be doing anything adult themed (seemed to imply she’d even avoid Maxim type things) I wouldn’t be surprised to see her break that promise. A lot of money is going to be thrown her way for that.

  5. Jason

    Funny post! A few of these were eerily close. Thanks!

  6. WildBluff_Matt

    Glad you enjoyed it Jason!

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy: Play nice. If you disagree, do so intelligently and respectfully. Comments with curse words will be edited. Comments stuffed with links will be queued to help prevent spam. Thanks!

Pingbacks & Trackbacks:

  1. Idol Stalker - Watching American Idol - American Idol Finalists Separated at Birth

    [...] WildBluffWalt at Wild Bluff Media has some interesting side-by-side comparisons to see exactly what kind of image some contestants are putting out there for the audience. [...]

  2. Go for Gusto » Blog Archive » Go For Gusto has been adopted by Wild Bluff Media!

    [...] favorite so far has been Phil Stacey as Nosferatu, part of our American Idol Separated at Birth [...]

  3. American Idol’s Sanjaya as Katherine McPhee | Wild Bluff Media : Entertainment Examined

    [...] picture has been floating around the internet for a bit now. I have to say when we did the American Idol Separated at Birth post, Katherine McPhee didn’t come to mind. No one seems to know who made it, but its really [...]

  4. American Idol: Sanjaya Charity | Wild Bluff Media : Entertainment Examined

    [...] you liked this one, check out American Idol Separated at Birth Entertained? Please Share It: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can [...]

  5. American Idol: Top 10 Performance Recap March 27 | Wild Bluff Media : Entertainment Examined

    [...] Stacey: “Every Breath You Take” Mr. Nosferatu actually did a really good job. I’ve always liked The Police, so maybe I’m just biased [...]

  6. American Idol: Top 6 Again Performance Show Preview - May 1, 2007 | Wild Bluff Media : Entertainment Examined

    [...] Melinda Doolittle and Jordin Sparks, and even without them I don’t think he could beat out Phil Nosferatu Stacey or Blake [...]

  7. Sarcasm Aside » Archivio Blog » American I-doppelgangers

    [...] Hasselhoff remark. Jack is the son of Black Sabbath’s bat-head-devouring Ozzy Osbourne. This blog thought Chris S looked like a topiary. [...]